The plans, which were considered in the second reading Monday after the first reading was approved in April, included 351 single-family homes on about 184 acres.
In April, commissioners debated at length about putting in a roundabout on Nonaville Road. City engineer Andy Barlow recommended the roundabout.
The roundabout was a cause for concern among commissioners again Monday, as there was some worry that many traveling through the area will haul boats and trailers through the roundabout. Commissioners also had general traffic concerns.
Ray Justice, who is the commissioner for the district where the proposed development is located, was strongly opposed to the roundabout.
Mayor Ed Hagerty, Justice and Brian Abston voted against the preliminary plans.
In April, commissioners agreed to allow developer Danny Hale to voluntarily contribute an additional $1,250 per lot to go toward additional improvements in the area, rather than the normally recommended amount of $2,500 per lot. Hale would have also been responsible for putting in sidewalks going to Lebanon Road.
In the preliminary plans, the existing amenities center would have remained, and a community swimming pool would have been built. The site also would have dedicated green space that would include an existing lake.
According to Hale, if the project were approved, it would take 10 years before it was completed.
If the developer wishes to attempt to move forward with a modified version of the project, it will need to go before the Mt. Juliet Planning Commission and, if approved, may then be reconsidered by the city commission.